Premier League: Similar results but different Uniteds

Newcastle host Manchester in the battle of the Uniteds tonight. Both have had similar results of late, but only Newcastle can take many positives from them, writes John Roycroft.
Premier League: Similar results but different Uniteds

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe (centre) applauds the fans at the end of the UEFA Champions League Group F match at the Parc des Princes in Paris, . 

TONIGHT'S battle of the Uniteds takes place at a very late time, for a Saturday game, at 8pm, as Newcastle United play host to Manchester United at St James’ Park.

The reason for the late kick-off arises from the midweek exertions for both sides, playing away in the Champions League. While both sides gave up leads to come away with a similar drawn result, there will be significantly different moods in either camp with the single point achieved.

Newcastle can take a great deal more satisfaction from the effort made in their draw on Tuesday against PSG. And but for another dreadful interpretation of the hand-ball rule by VAR, in the last seconds of an eight-minute injury-time extension to the game, they were set to claim a memorable victory against their fellow oil barons in Paris.

The Geordie side played with a well-balanced and organised defensive structure that effectively shut down the vaunted Paris attack for the guts of a 100 minutes.

The Kylian Mbappe penalty ensured PSG are still well in the hunt to qualify for the knockout stages. While Newcastle will have to beat Milan away and hope that Dortmund do them a favour against the Parisians if they hope to make it out of this aptly named ‘group of death’.

PSG's Kylian Mbappe, right, scores his side's goal from the penalty spot during the Champions League group F soccer match against Newcastle United at the Parc des Princes in Paris, Tuesday, Picture: AP Photo/Christophe Ena
PSG's Kylian Mbappe, right, scores his side's goal from the penalty spot during the Champions League group F soccer match against Newcastle United at the Parc des Princes in Paris, Tuesday, Picture: AP Photo/Christophe Ena

This may prove a bridge too far for the Geordies to achieve, but few would have seen them still in contention in match day 6 when the draw was made this summer and we saw the illustrious company lined up against them.

If Newcastle’s Champions League fate comes down to the penalty awarded against Tino Livramento at the Parc des Princes, then Newcastle can feel rightly hard done by, especially when Uefa seemingly have accepted the hand-ball decision as an error when they stood down the VAR official the very next day.

Regrets

On the other side of the spectrum, Man United will look back at their Wednesday night draw against Galatasaray with a mixture of regret, anger and bewilderment.

Manchester United's head coach Erik ten Hag shouts instructions during the Champions League group A soccer match against Galatasaray in Istanbul, Turkey. Picture: AP Photo
Manchester United's head coach Erik ten Hag shouts instructions during the Champions League group A soccer match against Galatasaray in Istanbul, Turkey. Picture: AP Photo

After overcoming the feared ‘Welcome to Hell’ atmosphere of Istanbul to take a two-goal lead and again pushing on to go 3-1 up in the second half, they somehow contrived, AGAIN, to squander their advantage and let the Turkish side claim a deserved draw from a thrilling, frantic, and definitely tactically naive encounter.

The best and worst in United was on show again on Wednesday night. The strikes and build up to Garnacho, Fernandes and McTominay’s goals were exciting and showed some accomplished ing that few sides would have an answer to. But the United defence was shambolic in comparison. Early on, Galatasaray showed their danger from set-pieces but United ignored the signals and continued to give away free-kicks in dangerous positions, which Kerem Akturkoglu was more than happy to dispatch to the net, albeit with a great deal of help from Andre Onana in the United goal. The Cameroonian shot-stopper has steadied his form in the Premier League but has had a nightmarish run of mishaps in the Champions League this season.

Manchester United's Harry Maguire, left, reacts after Galatasaray's Kerem Akturkoglu scored his side's third goal during the Champions League group A soccer match in Istanbul, Turkey, Picture: AP Photo
Manchester United's Harry Maguire, left, reacts after Galatasaray's Kerem Akturkoglu scored his side's third goal during the Champions League group A soccer match in Istanbul, Turkey, Picture: AP Photo

But beyond Onana's rubber hands, the United defending was woeful and that is not just the case for the actual defenders alone. There is a collective frailty across the team when they don’t have possession of the ball. Too many individuals in the team find it ok to opt out when it comes to getting the ball back.

In this season’s Champions League campaign alone, United have managed to squander leads on five occasions across three games, two from two-goal leads. They have also conceded four penalties in five games, and it could have been five from five, had the same VAR official at the Newcastle game been officiating in Istanbul.

Indeed, Eddie Howe must have ruefully looked on when the similar Man United handball, as his player’s infringement, was merely waved away by the referee.

Same but different

Both Uniteds now face must-win final games to their groups, the week after next. Man United may have the advantage here as they are at home to an already qualified Bayern Munich, while Newcastle face an AC Milan side that are still in with a chance themselves. Although Newcastle will have the advantage of no doubt having a fervent home crowd shouting them on.

Before all that, the sixth and seventh placed sides meet tonight in their domestic league. Again, after having very similar seasons so far, with some impressive wins, followed by disturbing defeats. The difference here for the two Uniteds being that Newcastle’s failings were more down to having key talent absent due to injury, while the Manchester version were losing due to their near allergic-like revulsion to defending.

Read More

Premier League: Everton look like the fall-guys for league's failings

more Cork Soccer articles

Republic of Ireland Training Session and Media Conference Adam Idah: 'I don't have to stay inside all the time - I'm human'
Brentford
2nd June 2025.
Transfer News Cork's Caoimhín Kelleher buzzing to get going at new club Brentford
Brentford
2nd June 2025.
Transfer News Caoimhín Kelleher windfall a reward for 'fantastic work' done by Cork soccer club 

More in this section

Cork U14 ladies footballers beat Galway after extra time in epic All-Ireland final Cork U14 ladies footballers beat Galway after extra time in epic All-Ireland final
Kerry v Cork - Electric Ireland Munster GAA Football Minor Championship Final Boost for Cork minor footballers as captain Cathal McCarthy wins red card appeal
Cork boxers bring back more All-Ireland titles to the Rebel County Cork boxers bring back more All-Ireland titles to the Rebel County

Sponsored Content

Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event  Digital advertising in focus at Irish Examiner’s Lunch & Learn event 
Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival  Experience a burst of culture with Cork Midsummer Festival 
How to get involved in Bike Week 2025 How to get involved in Bike Week 2025
Us Cookie Policy and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited

Add Echolive.ie to your home screen - easy access to Cork news, views, sport and more